Review: BLACK SKIES by Arnaldur Indriðason

BlackSkiesIndridasonHaving complained at length about authors who persist in producing the same book over and over again I applaud Arnaldur Indriðason’s willingness to experiment by allowing different protagonists to drive his novels. The fact that he has pulled it off very successfully, for the second time in a row, is a triumph.

BLACK SKIES is the eighth novel in the Reykjavik series of police procedurals but the second one in succession in which the series’ main character, detective Erlunder, is absent from his workplace (for reasons none of his co-workers seem sure of) and the novel. The story takes place in 2005 during the height of Iceland’s economic boom and at the same time as events described in the previous novel OUTRAGE, but here the investigative duties fall to another of Erlunder’s colleagues Sigurdur Óli. It opens with Sigurdur Óli attending a reunion of his high school class at which he feels himself to be the least successful of his classmates, many of whom are making it big in the new economy. However one of those people soon calls on him for a favour. Would Sigurdur Óli mind putting a bit of unofficial pressure on a couple who are blackmailing the man’s sister-in-law and her husband who took part in a wife-swapping escapade? When Sigurdur Óli goes to the blackmailing couple’s house on this errand he finds the woman on the floor with her head bashed in. He attempts to chase the assailant who was still on the scene but soon loses him. For understandable but not terribly clever reasons Sigurdur Óli doesn’t immediately come clean with his colleagues regarding the personal reason for his visit to the woman’s house and so assists with the official investigation while continuing to carry on his own inquiries due to the knowledge that only he possesses.

It is only now that I’ve sat down to write a review containing an even vaguely intelligent synopsis that I’ve realised just how complex and intricate the plot of BLACK SKIES is. Indriðason really is a master at telling stories with lots of layers that don’t make the reader feel like they’re reading a creative writing thesis rather than a novel. It’s bloody great art. Just as you think the book is going to focus on the sexual shenanigans of bored suburbanites it twists to offer the possibility of a drug deal gone bad. And then another turn….what are the wretched bankers up to and how might it relate to the death of a tour guide? Indriðason ties this all together beautifully and manages to encircle the investigative narrative with another thread that follows the story of a derelict called Anders who keeps crossing Sigurdur Óli’s path. His story, slowly revealed over the course of the novel, is a heartbreaking one and despite his self-confessed and innate sense of superiority over people like Anders the case becomes something of a watershed for Sigurdur Óli,

Another element that elevates BLACK SKIES above the norm for me is the character of Sigurdur Óli. He bares few of the traits of the great and memorable fictional cops. He’s not a genius, he’s not a workaholic, he’s not tortured by the souls of the deaths he has investigated. He’s a pretty ordinary guy doing a job he fell into and some days he’d rather be doing something else. But even without the trappings of the genre’s stalwarts he is still a wonderfully drawn character who we do see struggle with some aspects of his life, working out how his marriage failed for example, while trying to do a good job even when he doesn’t like his work and maintaining his moral core in the face of pressure. He is, I suspect, a lot closer to real cops than many of his more famous fictional brethren.

There’s much more I could talk about, including the novel’s unpacking of Iceland’s part in the global economic meltdown which is fascinating, but I think it’s time to simply recommend the book without qualification. It’s one of those crime novels I think could be read and enjoyed by non crime fans too and I don’t think you need to have read the earlier novels in the series in order to read this one. I’ve never been so frustrated by my own monolingual status as I am at knowing this book’s sequel is available but only if I can learn to read Icelandic.

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
Translator Victoria Cribb
Publisher Harvill Secker [2012]
ISBN/ASIN 9781846555404
Length 330 pages
Format paperback
Book Series #8 in the Reykjavik series

Creative Commons Licence
This work by is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

This entry was posted in Arnaldur Indriðason, book review, Iceland. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Review: BLACK SKIES by Arnaldur Indriðason

  1. Margot Kinberg says:

    Bernadette – A lovely review as ever. Indriðason is in my opinion a brilliant writer and you’ve captured here one of the things I like best about his writing. He’s able to weave a complex plot with a lot of strands and threads, but do so in a way that doesn’t tire the reader. It is a rare skill.


  2. Sarah says:

    Black Skies was a 5 star read for me last year. I agree about the author taking risks. I enjoyed seeing the action from Sigurdur Óli’s perspective and getting to know hos character a bit more. Glad you enjoyed it too!


  3. Mrs P. says:

    Thanks very much for this excellent review, Bernadette. I haven’t read Black Skies yet, but you’ve summed up my feelings about this series exactly. As far as I’m concerned Indridason can do no wrong. Like you, I’m very taken with his willingness to push the boundaries of the series through different narrative perspectives. I loved seeing things through Elinborg’s female eyes in Outrage (it gave us a new, reverse view of Erlendur as well, which was great).


  4. Kathy D. says:

    How much do I love Indridason’s writing? Let me count the ways. I have liked, no, loved nearly every book in the Erlendur series, with few exceptions. But the last three, Black Skies, Outrage and Hypothermia have been superb.
    Your review is quite good and captures my views of the book, too.
    And, yes, I wish I could read Icelandic, too, so I could purchase the next in the series. I buy few series’ books, but I always want to read these books right away.


  5. Pingback: Books of the Month – February 2013 | Reactions to Reading

  6. Pingback: International Dagger 2013 – Reading Progress and Speculation – #2 | Reactions to Reading

  7. Belle Wong says:

    I really want to read this one! I’m so psyched – I popped over to my library’s site and they actually have it (I find with my library it’s a bit hit and miss with some of the Euro titles you review here). What really drew me in was your description of Sigurdur Óli – sometimes I just get tired of the protagonist who’s the tortured genius, or the driven workaholic who hits the bottle a bit too much, or who suffers terribly as he/she communes too deeply with the souls of the victims. An ordinary guy trying to get his job done. The plot twists sound great, too.


    • My library is a bit hit or miss on the Euro titles too Belle 🙂 It took me about half the book to work out what it was about the character that was resonating with me…until I realised it was ‘cos he was like me – or people I know – a bit disgruntled to find out he wasn’t quite the adult he probably imagined he might be (surely no one dreams of ‘just getting by’) but still putting in the effort required to do his job most of the time – I could relate to him – even his less pleasant characteristics 🙂


  8. Pingback: Petrona Award and more | Scandinavian Crime Fiction

  9. Pingback: Can there be four winners? | Reactions to Reading

Comments are closed.