Review: Valley of the Lost by Vicki Delany

Title: Valley of the Lost

Author: Vicki Delany

Publisher:Blackstone Audiobooks [2009]

ISBN: n/a (digital download via

Length: 9hours 34 minutes

Narrator: Carrington MacDuffie

In the small town of Trafalgar in the hinterland of British Columbia, Canada, ageing hippie Lucky Smith finds the body of a young woman in the woods near the women’s support centre where she works. Lying by the body is a crying baby boy. The police, including Lucky’s daughter Molly who is a probationary constable, soon realise that the dead woman has hidden her past well and they struggle to piece together what might have happened to the young mother. Some are quick to write the death off to the relapse of a heroin junkie but Sergeant John Winters wonders if there’s more to it. As the investigation proceeds Lucky looks after the baby, fighting off a determined social services officer in the process.

Although the mystery itself unfurls relatively slowly it doesn’t matter as there’s lots going on and I was quickly drawn into the world the author had created here. As is the way with small towns, many of the people know each other and the author does a great job of introducing the various characters and making the reader care about them by showing snippets of their day-to-day lives. Alongside the Smith family and the engaging lead investigator there are a host of other people who play roles that may not have anything to do with the mystery but are still people you want to know more about. If you’d suggested to me before I read this book that someone could make me even vaguely interested in a character who was an ex-super model I’d have laughed at you but Eliza, John Winters’ wife, is a delight as she wrestles with her own career crisis while supporting her husband in his demanding job.

The book is a combination whodunit and police procedural and offers the best of both. Winters doggedly interviews and re-interviews people who he thinks might know something about the dead girl’s past. In this way the various potential suspects are slowly fleshed-out and the pool narrowed down. The resolution is ultimately quite complex but credible within the context of the story and very easy to follow.

I’m also thrilled to point out that Delany has succeeded in incorporating the political/social commentary into the story via character traits or story threads as authors are supposed to do. Unlike this book and this one, both recent reads, I didn’t feel like I was being lectured to like a naughty (or stupid) schoolgirl and so was far more willing to contemplate the important themes being raised in the story.

This was a thoroughly entertaining book with a whole host of great characters and a multi-faceted plot and I’ll be looking for more books by Vicky Delany.

Audio-book specific comments: The narration is excellent with MacDuffie managing to make it clear which of the many characters is speaking with only minor differences in her tone or inflection. Normally I listen to audio books while doing something else but with this one I sat in my reading chair and listened to the last hour or so just to enjoy being read to.

My rating 4/5

Other stuff

Reviewed by Lesa at Lesa’s Book Critiques

Reviewed by Kerrie at Mysteries in Paradise (whose review prompted me to seek this book out)

This is the second book in Delany’s series featuring John Winters and Molly Smith and she has also written some standalone novels. As well as having her own website Delany is one of the authors who publish the group blog Type M for Murder (one of the group blogs I didn’t feature in last Sunday’s post about this phenomenon)

This entry was posted in book review, Canada, Vicki Delany. Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to Review: Valley of the Lost by Vicki Delany

  1. Dorte H says:

    No audio books for me, but the plot & environment sound just great: village + whodunnit with great characters, and I am usually sold.


  2. bernadetteinoz says:

    Dorte I walk a fair bit (an hour or so to work each day for a start) so I like to do something with that time. Even if you read this one ‘the old fashioned way’ I think you’d like it 🙂


  3. Beth F says:

    Wow: This one suits both my audiobook addiction and my mystery addiction. I’ll definitely look for this. I love the cover too!


  4. Beth F says:

    Just found this on OverDrive (free digital download from the library) and I’m so happy they have the first one too — I hate reading mystery series out of order.


  5. Cathy says:

    I just purchased the first book in the series, and after reading your review of this, I’m really looking forward to reading it!


  6. Maxine says:

    This sounds (ha ha) very good, Bernadette. I don’t usually listen to books either, but will look out for a printed version. Great review, thank you.


  7. bernadetteinoz says:

    I hope any of you who read the book enjoy it too

    And I’m starting to see there are two types of people in the world – audio book listeners and non-audio book listeners. I might have to look into this for a future post.


  8. Dorte H says:

    Bernadette, as a teacher I think it has something to do with learning styles. I am completely unable to learn anything via the ear alone (and so are my daughters). If I don´t have pictures or letters with it it just doesn´t stay. I don´t like listening to radio news or programmes either – I have never been good at concentrating and today with my chronic fatigue I don´t even bother to try.


  9. Sherry says:

    I added a link to your review to my Saturday Review of Books at Semicolon. Please feel free to add links to all your reviews each Saturday at


  10. Pingback: Review: The Calling by Inger Ash Wolfe « Reactions to Reading

  11. Pingback: Review: Winter of Secrets by Vicky Delany « Reactions to Reading

  12. Mason Canyon says:

    Sounds like an interesting story and one that would be perfect to listen to on audio.

    Thoughts in Progress


  13. Anonymous says:

    If you listen to this on audio and you’re a Canadian from BC you will be annoyed by the pronunciation of the ‘Kootenays” (she says koo-ten -aays it’s koo-ten-eeeys) and Kokanee… Also, I don’t know any small community in BC that has it’s own police force. I live in a small town of 7,000 and we have RCMP contracted here… So I guess between the mis-pronunciation and the a few unrealistic facts, it makes this book hard to listen to. A bit of fluff for my tastes.


Comments are closed.